Let $ a$ be the greatest positive root of the equation $ x^3 - 3 \cdot x^2 + 1 = 0.$ Show that $ \left[a^{1788} \right]$ and $ \left[a^{1988} \right]$ are both divisible by 17. Here $ [x]$ denotes the integer part of $ x.$
Problem
Source: IMO Shortlist 1988, Problem 7, IMO Longlist 10
Tags: algebra, polynomial, modular arithmetic, number theory, Divisibility, IMO Shortlist
06.11.2005 10:11
Here's a sketch of an answer. Let $a > b > c$ be the three real roots of $f(x) = x^3 - 3x^2 + 1$ and note that $a > 1 > b > 0 > c > -1$. Let $t_n = a^n + b^n + c^n$. Write down the first three values of $t_n$ and note that it satisfies a recurrence relation with driving polynomial $f$: that is, $t_{n+3} = 3t_{n+2} - t_n$. Reduce modulo 17, find the cycles and check that $t_{1788}$ and $t_{1988}$ are zero mod 17. Finally observe that $t_N$ = $\lfloor a^N \rfloor$ for large even $N$ since $\vert b \vert, \vert c \vert < 1$.
13.07.2007 20:04
Actually (and fortunately ) you should check that $ t_{1788}$ and $ t_{1988}$ are 1 mod 17, and then observe, that since $ 1>|b|>|c|$ and $ b>0>c$ and $ b^{2}+c^{2}<2$, $ 0<b^{k}+c^{k}<1$ and thus $ 1\equiv t_{1788}>t_{1788}-b^{1788}-c^{1788}=a^{1788}>[a^{1788}]=t_{1788}\equiv0\pmod{17}$. Same with 1988.
13.07.2007 21:01
Finding the cycles could be a bit boring... Maybe it is more easy to prove that $ a^{n}+b^{n}+c^{n}\equiv 4^{n}+5^{n}+11^{n}\pmod{17}$
14.07.2007 11:23
piever wrote: Finding the cycles could be a bit boring... Maybe it is more easy to prove that $ a^{n}+b^{n}+c^{n}\equiv 4^{n}+5^{n}+11^{n}\pmod{17}$ And then finding the cycles again for $ 4^{n}$, $ 5^{n}$ and $ 11^{n}$... But you're right, it is clearly visible that their cycles' lengths are at most 16, which is not evident at the $ t_{i}$ sequence. However the latter cycle's length is 16, so this is not a big problem. Another thing is, i don't think your identity shines from $ t_{n}$
16.01.2009 23:09
I solved for a. Let a-1=k, then we have $ k^3 = 3k + 1$ Let $ k = 2cos m$, then we have $ 2(4cos^3m - 3cosm) = 1$ $ cos(3m) = 1/2$ $ 3m = 60$ gives the largest root. So $ a = 2cos20 + 1$ The other roots are $ 2cos100 + 1$ and $ 2 cos 140 + 1$ Is it possible to solve it this way?
16.08.2009 23:59
How could someone better explain this problem and fully reverse the recurrence is not my thing but it is very clear. Thanks in advance. Greetings