In a country, there are some two-way roads between the cities. There are $2010$ roads connected to the capital city. For all cities different from the capital city, there are less than $2010$ roads connected to that city. For two cities, if there are the same number of roads connected to these cities, then this number is even. $k$ roads connected to the capital city will be deleted. It is wanted that whatever the road network is, if we can reach from one city to another at the beginning, then we can reach after the deleting process also. Find the maximum value of $k.$
Problem
Source:
Tags: ceiling function, combinatorics proposed, combinatorics
17.12.2010 23:38
is $k_{max}=0$ the correct answer?
18.12.2010 00:23
Dumel wrote: is $k_{max}=0$ the correct answer? Unfortunately.
18.12.2010 02:53
Let $G(V,E)$ be the corresponding graph; wlog it is connected. Let $v_0$ be the capital city. Delete $v_0$ and all it's edges. We are left with $m$ disjoint connected components $C_1,...,C_m$. To each component we add a copy of $v_0$, (i.e. $m$ copies of $v_0$ so the components are still disjoint). Note that $\sum_{i=1}^m d_{C_i}(v_0)=2010$ (*) and that we can delete $d_{C_i}(v_0)-1$ edges from $v_0$ for all $i$ and leave the original graph connected. Therefore we can delete $2010-m$ edges in the original graph, so the problem reduces to maximising the number of components. If $d_{C_i}(v_0)$ is odd then $C_i$ has another vertex of odd degree (because $\sum_{v\in V}d(v)=2|E|$ is even). However, if two components have vertices of the same degree then that degree is even. Since all vertices are degree $\le 2009$, it follows that there are at most $\lceil \textstyle\frac{2009}{2}\rceil = 1005$ components with $d_{C_i}(v_0)$ odd. However, from (*) we cannot have an odd number of components with $d_{C_i}(v_0)$ odd, so there are at most $1004$ components with $d_{C_i}(v_0)=1$. Hence, all other components have degree $\ge 2$ so we can delete at least $\textstyle\frac{2010-1004}{2}=503$ edges. To show this is achievable consider the following: Join $1004$ edges from $v_0$ to the disjoint complete graphs $K_3,K_5,...,K_{2009}$. Then join $1006$ edges from $v_0$ to the vertices of $503$ disjoint $K_2$. Hence $k_{\text{max}}=503$.
18.12.2010 12:44
what about this counter(?)example ? Image not found it seems me that all of the conditions are satisfied, but we can delete the edge between the capital city and 2000. ocha wrote: To show this is achievable consider the following: Join $1004$ edges from $v_0$ to the disjoint complete graphs $K_3,K_5,...,K_{2009}$. Then join $1006$ edges from $v_0$ to the vertices of $503$ disjoint $K_2$. or possibly I misuderstood sth coz the above example looks similar to mine.
18.12.2010 16:33
You can delete 1997 edges from $v_0$ to the complete bipartite graph and leave it connected...?
18.12.2010 19:19
ok so you found maximum value of k such that it's always possible to delete k edges leaving graph connected? However I have still understood the problem is to find maximum k such that no matter which k edges we delete, graph remains connected; Quote: there are (...) at least, $2010-1004=1006$ components with even degree $\ge 2$. even for m<1006? //in the above construction I obviously confused 2000 with 2010