Show that the sequence \[\binom{2002}{2002},\binom{2003}{2002},\binom{2004}{2002},\ldots \] considred modulo $2002$, is periodic.
Problem
Source: Baltic Way 2002
Tags: number theory proposed, number theory
13.11.2010 18:15
Consider as polinom $P(x)=\binom {x+m}{m}=\frac{(x+m)...(x+1)}{m!}$. Obviosly $P(x+m^2)\equiv P(x)\mod m$.
13.08.2014 08:38
Rust wrote: Consider as polinom $P(x)=\binom {x+m}{m}=\frac{(x+m)...(x+1)}{m!}$. Obviosly $P(x+m^2)\equiv P(x)\mod m$. How?!
11.09.2018 19:55
Rust wrote: Consider as polinom $P(x)=\binom {x+m}{m}=\frac{(x+m)...(x+1)}{m!}$. Obviosly $P(x+m^2)\equiv P(x)\mod m$. This is just false. Take e.g. $m=6$. Then $\binom{n}{6}$ has minimal period $8$ modulo $2$ and hence can't have period $36$ modulo $6$.
12.09.2018 10:16
We can show that ${x\choose m}$ is periodic modulo any integer $a\ge 1$. Let $P=[x]_m=x\cdots (x-m+1)$ then $P(x+am!)\equiv P(x) \mod am!$. Hence we have ${{x+am!}\choose m}={{P(x+am!})\over {m!}}\equiv {{P(x)}\over {m!}}={x\choose m}\mod a$.
12.09.2018 10:20
Another way (which is also the official solution) is to note that if $\binom{x}{n}$ is periodic modulo $m$ with period $p$, then $\binom{x}{n+1}$ is periodic modulo $m$ with period $mp$. Then by induction we find something like a period of $m^m$ since $\binom{x}{0}$ clearly is periodic. In fact the period of $\binom{x}{n}$ modulo a prime $p$ has been well-studied and one can show that the minimal period is equal to the smallest power of $p$ larger than $n$.
12.09.2018 15:59
When $m=\prod_i p_i$, by Lucas theorem, $\binom{n}{m}\equiv \prod_{i=1}^k \binom{n_i}{m_i}\equiv \binom{1}{0}\prod_{i=1}^k \binom{n_i}{m_i}\equiv \binom{n+p_i^{k+1}}{m}\pmod{p_i}$ So the period can be $\prod_i p_i^{[log_{p_i}m]+1}$. For example, m=6, $\prod_i p_i^{[log_{p_i}6]+1}=2^3\times 3^2=72$
14.09.2018 00:32
The Periodic Property of Binomial Coecients Modulo m and Its Applications $\binom{n+p^{k+[log_p m]}}{m}\equiv \binom{n}{m}\pmod{p^k}$ It's found that the minimum period of $\binom{n}{m}\pmod{N=\prod_i p_i^{k_i}}$ is $\prod_i p_i^{k_i+[log_{p_i} m ] }=N\prod_i p_i^{[log_{p_i} m]}$
27.10.2022 16:39