Let $n$ be a positive integer. On a number line, Azer is at point $0$ in his car which have fuel capacity of $2^n$ units and is initially full. At each positive integer $m$, there is a gas station. Azer only moves to the right with constant speed and doesn't stop anywhere except the gas stations. Each time his car moves to the right by some amount, its fuel decreases by the same amount. Azer may choose to stop at a gas station or pass it. There are thieves at some gas stations. (A station may have multiple thieves) If Azer stops at a station which have $k\ge 0$ thieves while its car have fuel capacity $d$, his cars new fuel capacity becomes $\frac{d}{2^k}$. After that, Azer fulls his cars tank and leaves the station. Find the minimum number of thieves needed to guarantee that Azer will eventually run out of fuel. Proposed by Mehmet Can Baştemir and Deniz Can Karaçelebi
Problem
Source: Turkey Olympic Revenge 2024 P6
Tags: combinatorics, algebra
07.08.2024 10:32
Answer: $2^{n+1}-1$ Example: If there is one thief at every station $m=1,2,3,\cdots,2^{n+1}-1$, then Azer can not make it through. Every time he stops, the fuel capacity is halved, so after going $2^n+2^{n-1}+\cdots+2^1+2^0=2^{n+1}-1$ units, the fuel capacity drops below 1 and he can not continue anymore. Now, assume we have less than $2^{n+1}-1$ thieves and we will show there is a way for Azer to pass all thieves with at least 1 fuel. The friend of Azer, Ilham, helps Azer by going through all stations to create a strategy for him. Ilham has $2^i$ hats with color $c_i$ for $i=0,1,2,\cdots,n$. He passes this number line $n+1$ times, for $i=n,n-1,n-2,\cdots,0$, every time starting from 0, and goes as long as he still has hats with color $c_i$, that is until he distributes all of his hats with color $c_i$, or until there is no more thieves along the way to give hats. And then he goes back to 0 to start the next round. In every round, whenever he sees a station with at least one thief who does not wear a hat, he gives one of them the hat with color $c_i$ to wear. After these rounds, since the number of hats ($2^{n+1}-1$) is greater than the number of thieves, Ilham has at least one hat left. If a hat with color $c_n$ is left: That means, in the first round, Ilham sees less than $2^n$ stations with at least one thief. So, Azer finds a safe spot in any consecutive $2^n$ stations and since he starts with $2^n$ fuel, he can refill at those safe spot and pass without even seeing a single thief. If a hat with color other than $c_n$ is left: In this case, we will show that there is a route such that Azer sees at most one thief with color $c_i$ for every $i$, and also there is at least one color such that Azer never sees a thief with hat of that color. This proves the capacity is halved at most $n$ times and with a capacity of at least $2^0=1$, Azer can continue indefinitely. Ilham, tries to find such a route to help Azer, but accidentally, he does not take into account the thieves with hat of color $c_n$. Since there is no hat of color $c_n$ left, the total number of thieves with other colors is less than $2^n-1$, so by induction, Ilham finds a route such that Azer sees at most one thief with color $c_i$ for every $i=0,1,2,\cdots, n-1$, and also there is at least one color such that Azer never sees a thief with hat of that color. However, he may encounter multiple thieves with hat of color $c_n$ in this strategy since Ilham accidentally ignored them. Now, we will fix that. Since $c_n$ hats are distributed in the first round, there is number $s$ such that the first $s$ station either is empty or includes a thief with color $c_n$. And after $s$ stations, there is no thieves with hat color $c_n$. To fix his suggestion, Ilham removes the stations with a thief of color $c_n$ in it except for the last one. By induction, we know the old suggestion works if we started with $2^{n-1}$ fuel and ignored $c_n$. Now, we will show that Azer can reach this station with a $c_n$ in it in the new suggestion and we are done. Since we have $2^n$ stations with $c_n$ in it, until reaching the last station with $c_n$, Ilham only observes stations either empty or $c_n$ in it. Even if there is no empty station to refill, Azer can reach the last station with $c_n$ located at $m=2^n$ since the starting fuel is sufficient for this.
07.08.2024 11:01
Also, I think we can find all the possible distributions of $2^{n+1}-1$ thieves such that Azer can not pass through. I feel like for every $i>j$, the last thief with color $c_j$ is not behind the last thief with color $c_i$. For example, when $n=2$, we find the situations below where blue is $c_2$, green is $c_1$ and red is $c_0$. [asy][asy] size(10cm); real a = 1.0, b = 1.0; int m = 7, n = 11; real w = a*m, h = b*n; path out = (-1, -1) -- (-1, h+1) -- (w+1, h+1) -- (w+1, -1) -- cycle; pen blue = RGB(80, 80, 255), green = RGB(80, 255, 80), red = RGB(255, 80, 80); void fill_cell(int row, int column, pen color) { fill((row*a, column*b) -- (row*a+a, column*b) -- (row*a+a, column*b+b) -- (row*a, column*b+b) -- cycle, color); draw((row*a, column*b) -- (row*a+a, column*b) -- (row*a+a, column*b+b) -- (row*a, column*b+b) -- cycle, linewidth(1.0pt)); } void fill_cell_label(int row, int column, pen color, Label entry) { fill((row*a, column*b) -- (row*a+a, column*b) -- (row*a+a, column*b+b) -- (row*a, column*b+b) -- cycle, color); label(entry, (row*a+a/2, (n-column)*b+b/2), p = fontsize(20pt)); } void cell_label(int row, int column, Label entry) { label(entry, (row*a+a/2, (n-column)*b+b/2), p = fontsize(20pt)); } cell_label(0, 0, "1"); cell_label(1, 0, "2"); cell_label(2, 0, "3"); cell_label(3, 0, "4"); cell_label(4, 0, "5"); cell_label(5, 0, "6"); cell_label(6, 0, "7"); fill_cell(0, n - 1, blue); fill_cell(1, n - 1, blue); fill_cell(2, n - 1, blue); fill_cell(3, n - 1, blue); fill_cell(4, n - 1, green); fill_cell(5, n - 1, green); fill_cell(6, n - 1, red); fill_cell(0, n - 3, blue); fill_cell(1, n - 3, blue); fill_cell(2, n - 3, blue); fill_cell(3, n - 3, blue); fill_cell(4, n - 3, green); fill_cell(5, n - 3, green); fill_cell(5, n - 4, red); fill_cell(0, n - 6, blue); fill_cell(1, n - 6, blue); fill_cell(2, n - 6, blue); fill_cell(3, n - 6, blue); fill_cell(3, n - 7, green); fill_cell(4, n - 7, green); fill_cell(5, n - 7, red); fill_cell(0, n - 9, blue); fill_cell(1, n - 9, blue); fill_cell(2, n - 9, blue); fill_cell(3, n - 9, blue); fill_cell(3, n - 10, green); fill_cell(4, n - 10, green); fill_cell(4, n - 11, red); [/asy][/asy] [asy][asy] size(6cm); real a = 1.0, b = 1.0; int m = 7, n = 11; real w = a*m, h = b*n; path out = (-1, -1) -- (-1, h+1) -- (w+1, h+1) -- (w+1, -1) -- cycle; pen blue = RGB(80, 80, 255), green = RGB(80, 255, 80), red = RGB(255, 80, 80); void fill_cell(int row, int column, pen color) { fill((row*a, column*b) -- (row*a+a, column*b) -- (row*a+a, column*b+b) -- (row*a, column*b+b) -- cycle, color); draw((row*a, column*b) -- (row*a+a, column*b) -- (row*a+a, column*b+b) -- (row*a, column*b+b) -- cycle, linewidth(1.0pt)); } void fill_cell_label(int row, int column, pen color, Label entry) { fill((row*a, column*b) -- (row*a+a, column*b) -- (row*a+a, column*b+b) -- (row*a, column*b+b) -- cycle, color); label(entry, (row*a+a/2, (n-column)*b+b/2), p = fontsize(20pt)); } void cell_label(int row, int column, Label entry) { label(entry, (row*a+a/2, (n-column)*b+b/2), p = fontsize(20pt)); } cell_label(0, 0, "1"); cell_label(1, 0, "2"); cell_label(2, 0, "3"); cell_label(3, 0, "4"); cell_label(4, 0, "5"); cell_label(5, 0, "6"); cell_label(6, 0, "7"); fill_cell(0, n - 1, blue); fill_cell(1, n - 1, blue); fill_cell(2, n - 1, blue); fill_cell(3, n - 1, blue); fill_cell(2, n - 2, green); fill_cell(3, n - 2, green); fill_cell(4, n - 2, red); fill_cell(0, n - 4, blue); fill_cell(1, n - 4, blue); fill_cell(2, n - 4, blue); fill_cell(3, n - 4, blue); fill_cell(2, n - 5, green); fill_cell(3, n - 5, green); fill_cell(3, n - 6, red); [/asy][/asy]
12.08.2024 18:47
Not a hard problem but really interesting. First observation is, if previous gas stations $k<2^n$ have no thief, then the thieves before $k$ are all useless since Azer can skip them to $k.$ Now WLOG all the $k\le N$-th gas stations have at least one thief. Here we get the construction quickly: take $N=2^{n+1}-1.$ Each gas station $k\le N$ have one thief. Then obviously Azer needs to cross at least $n+1$ times before reaching $2^{n+1},$ and he cannot keep moving since $2^n/2^{n+1}=1/2<1.$ Now we only need to prove that if there are at most $2^{n+1}-2$ thieves, Azer can find a method to run forever. WLOG $1\sim 2^n$ have at least one thief, otherwise Azer first run to the station with no thief. Now there are at most $2^{n+1}-2-2^n=2^n-2$ more thieves, so simple idea is induction. Base case is trivial. Assume property holds for $n-1,$ consider $n.$ Azer first run to the $2^n$-th gas station. Then his new fuel capacity is $2^{n-1}$ and there are at most $2^{n-1}-2$ thieves after $2^n$. Use induction hypothesis and we are done. $\Box$
16.08.2024 00:38
EthanWYX2009 wrote: Azer first run to the $2^n$-th gas station. Then his new fuel capacity is $2^{n-1}$ and there are at most $2^{n-1}-2$ thieves after $2^n$. Use induction hypothesis and we are done. $\Box$ Nice solution! But what if the there are multiple thieves at $2^{n}$ along the number line?
29.12.2024 11:29
AnSoLiN wrote: Answer: $2^{n+1}-1$ Example: If there is one thief at every station $m=1,2,3,\cdots,2^{n+1}-1$, then Azer can not make it through. Every time he stops, the fuel capacity is halved, so after going $2^n+2^{n-1}+\cdots+2^1+2^0=2^{n+1}-1$ units, the fuel capacity drops below 1 and he can not continue anymore. Now, assume we have less than $2^{n+1}-1$ thieves and we will show there is a way for Azer to pass all thieves with at least 1 fuel. The friend of Azer, Ilham, helps Azer by going through all stations to create a strategy for him. Ilham has $2^i$ hats with color $c_i$ for $i=0,1,2,\cdots,n$. He passes this number line $n+1$ times, for $i=n,n-1,n-2,\cdots,0$, every time starting from 0, and goes as long as he still has hats with color $c_i$, that is until he distributes all of his hats with color $c_i$, or until there is no more thieves along the way to give hats. And then he goes back to 0 to start the next round. In every round, whenever he sees a station with at least one thief who does not wear a hat, he gives one of them the hat with color $c_i$ to wear. After these rounds, since the number of hats ($2^{n+1}-1$) is greater than the number of thieves, Ilham has at least one hat left. If a hat with color $c_n$ is left: That means, in the first round, Ilham sees less than $2^n$ stations with at least one thief. So, Azer finds a safe spot in any consecutive $2^n$ stations and since he starts with $2^n$ fuel, he can refill at those safe spot and pass without even seeing a single thief. If a hat with color other than $c_n$ is left: In this case, we will show that there is a route such that Azer sees at most one thief with color $c_i$ for every $i$, and also there is at least one color such that Azer never sees a thief with hat of that color. This proves the capacity is halved at most $n$ times and with a capacity of at least $2^0=1$, Azer can continue indefinitely. Ilham, tries to find such a route to help Azer, but accidentally, he does not take into account the thieves with hat of color $c_n$. Since there is no hat of color $c_n$ left, the total number of thieves with other colors is less than $2^n-1$, so by induction, Ilham finds a route such that Azer sees at most one thief with color $c_i$ for every $i=0,1,2,\cdots, n-1$, and also there is at least one color such that Azer never sees a thief with hat of that color. However, he may encounter multiple thieves with hat of color $c_n$ in this strategy since Ilham accidentally ignored them. Now, we will fix that. Since $c_n$ hats are distributed in the first round, there is number $s$ such that the first $s$ station either is empty or includes a thief with color $c_n$. And after $s$ stations, there is no thieves with hat color $c_n$. To fix his suggestion, Ilham removes the stations with a thief of color $c_n$ in it except for the last one. By induction, we know the old suggestion works if we started with $2^{n-1}$ fuel and ignored $c_n$. Now, we will show that Azer can reach this station with a $c_n$ in it in the new suggestion and we are done. Since we have $2^n$ stations with $c_n$ in it, until reaching the last station with $c_n$, Ilham only observes stations either empty or $c_n$ in it. Even if there is no empty station to refill, Azer can reach the last station with $c_n$ located at $m=2^n$ since the starting fuel is sufficient for this. Nice solution! But what if the last station with $c_n$ located at $m=2^n$ has thieves with color $c_i$ for $i=n,n-1,n-2,\cdots,0$ ?
29.12.2024 23:20
Wangguanhua wrote: AnSoLiN wrote: Answer: $2^{n+1}-1$ Example: If there is one thief at every station $m=1,2,3,\cdots,2^{n+1}-1$, then Azer can not make it through. Every time he stops, the fuel capacity is halved, so after going $2^n+2^{n-1}+\cdots+2^1+2^0=2^{n+1}-1$ units, the fuel capacity drops below 1 and he can not continue anymore. Now, assume we have less than $2^{n+1}-1$ thieves and we will show there is a way for Azer to pass all thieves with at least 1 fuel. The friend of Azer, Ilham, helps Azer by going through all stations to create a strategy for him. Ilham has $2^i$ hats with color $c_i$ for $i=0,1,2,\cdots,n$. He passes this number line $n+1$ times, for $i=n,n-1,n-2,\cdots,0$, every time starting from 0, and goes as long as he still has hats with color $c_i$, that is until he distributes all of his hats with color $c_i$, or until there is no more thieves along the way to give hats. And then he goes back to 0 to start the next round. In every round, whenever he sees a station with at least one thief who does not wear a hat, he gives one of them the hat with color $c_i$ to wear. After these rounds, since the number of hats ($2^{n+1}-1$) is greater than the number of thieves, Ilham has at least one hat left. If a hat with color $c_n$ is left: That means, in the first round, Ilham sees less than $2^n$ stations with at least one thief. So, Azer finds a safe spot in any consecutive $2^n$ stations and since he starts with $2^n$ fuel, he can refill at those safe spot and pass without even seeing a single thief. If a hat with color other than $c_n$ is left: In this case, we will show that there is a route such that Azer sees at most one thief with color $c_i$ for every $i$, and also there is at least one color such that Azer never sees a thief with hat of that color. This proves the capacity is halved at most $n$ times and with a capacity of at least $2^0=1$, Azer can continue indefinitely. Ilham, tries to find such a route to help Azer, but accidentally, he does not take into account the thieves with hat of color $c_n$. Since there is no hat of color $c_n$ left, the total number of thieves with other colors is less than $2^n-1$, so by induction, Ilham finds a route such that Azer sees at most one thief with color $c_i$ for every $i=0,1,2,\cdots, n-1$, and also there is at least one color such that Azer never sees a thief with hat of that color. However, he may encounter multiple thieves with hat of color $c_n$ in this strategy since Ilham accidentally ignored them. Now, we will fix that. Since $c_n$ hats are distributed in the first round, there is number $s$ such that the first $s$ station either is empty or includes a thief with color $c_n$. And after $s$ stations, there is no thieves with hat color $c_n$. To fix his suggestion, Ilham removes the stations with a thief of color $c_n$ in it except for the last one. By induction, we know the old suggestion works if we started with $2^{n-1}$ fuel and ignored $c_n$. Now, we will show that Azer can reach this station with a $c_n$ in it in the new suggestion and we are done. Since we have $2^n$ stations with $c_n$ in it, until reaching the last station with $c_n$, Ilham only observes stations either empty or $c_n$ in it. Even if there is no empty station to refill, Azer can reach the last station with $c_n$ located at $m=2^n$ since the starting fuel is sufficient for this. Nice solution! But what if the last station with $c_n$ located at $m=2^n$ has thieves with color $c_i$ for $i=n,n-1,n-2,\cdots,0$ ? That is not possible, because we are building the new suggestion on top of the initial suggestion which ignores $c_n$. So, in this station, we have all the hats of color $c_1,c_2,\cdots,c_{n-1}$ (ignoring $c_n$), so it can not be in the set of stations suggested initially, because of the induction hypothesis. We take a working suggestion for the case without $c_n$ and we just remove suggestions (if we need to) and do not add any. In the worst case where we do not remove any suggestions (because we already have a single $c_n$ in the suggested stations), the only difference between these two situations is that we have double starting fuel, and extra one thief with hat $c_n$. These cancel out.