On an $8\times 8$ chessboard, place a stick on each edge of each grid (on a common edge of two grid only one stick will be placed). What is the minimum number of sticks to be deleted so that the remaining sticks do not form any rectangle?
Problem
Source: Chinese Girls Mathematics Olympiads 2023
Tags: combinatorics
12.08.2023 15:11
The answer is $43$. Proof of minimality: for some given method to delete sticks, consider putting a piece on the board which is only allowed to move to an adjacent grid with no stick in-between. Grids are then divided into *blocks*: two grids are in the same block iff the piece can reach one from the other by a sequence of moves. Observe that every deleted stick belongs to exactly one block. The critical observation is that a block consisting of $n$ squares contains at least $n-1$ deleted sticks. The idea arises from the famous theorem in graph theory that the number of edges in a non-empty connected graph is no less than the number of vertices minus $1$. Also observe that blocks of $1,2$ grid(s) must contain at least $1,2$ deleted stick(s), correspondingly, to avoid rectangles. Therefore we verify that $$\#[\text{number of deleted sticks in a block}]\geq \frac{2}{3}\#[\text{number of grids in that block}]$$ thus the total number of deleted sticks $\geq 8\times 8\times\frac{2}{3}=42\frac{2}{3}$. Therefore it must be at least $43$.
19.08.2023 14:11
Construction: we follow the above theorem. Let's place a single square in the corner (with one edge deleted), and $L$-s (the pattern consisting of three squares but not a rectangle) elsewhere. There is a famous recursive pattern and it is easy to verify it works. The same goes for all chessboards with edge length a power of $2$.