Let $a_n$ be a sequence given by $a_1 = 18$, and $a_n = a_{n-1}^2+6a_{n-1}$, for $n>1$. Prove that this sequence contains no perfect powers.
Problem
Source: 2020 Caucasus Mathematical Olympiad
Tags: number theory, algebra, Sequence
16.03.2020 10:27
P.S. I didn't appear for this Olympiad, this is just a spontaneous solution.
16.03.2020 10:47
Was this from Day 1 or day 2? And, Juniors or seniors? Please specify in source the day, problem number and category, to avoid confusion while adding this to contest collections
16.03.2020 11:03
Math-wiz wrote:
P.S. I didn't appear for this Olympiad, this is just a spontaneous solution. It's day 1 for Juniors problem 3
16.03.2020 14:30
Math-wiz wrote:
P.S. I didn't appear for this Olympiad, this is just a spontaneous solution. why gcd(n+1,n+2)=1 makes a_n not a perfect power?
16.03.2020 14:56
mtahh wrote: Math-wiz wrote:
P.S. I didn't appear for this Olympiad, this is just a spontaneous solution. why gcd(n+1,n+2)=1 makes a_n not a perfect power? Because if $a_n=x^y$ for positive integers $x,y$, then $y|n+1$ and $y|n+2$ which is not possible as $gcd(n+1,n+2)=1$
16.03.2020 15:40
if i'm not mistaken, you have skipped the most important part in this problem, which is proving this math-wiz said wrote: One can prove inductively that for $n\geq 2$, $\nu_2(b_n)=n+1$ and $\nu_3(b_n)=n$
16.03.2020 15:50
It can be done easily by induction. Base case $k=2$ is true $b_2=6b_1(b_1+1)=6*3*4=2^3*3^2$ $\nu_2(b_2)=3=2+1, \nu_3(b_2)=2$ For $k=3,4,\ldots n$, let $\nu_2(b_k)=k+1, \nu_3(b_k)=k$ We prove it for $k=n+1$ $\nu_2(b_{n+1})=\nu_2(6b_n(b_n+1))=\nu_2(6)+\nu_2(b_n)+\nu_2(b_n+1)=1+(n+1)+0=n+2$ $\nu_3(b_{n+1})=\nu_3(6b_n(b_n+1))=\nu_3(6)+\nu_3(b_n)+\nu_3(b_n+1)=1+n+0=n+1$ And the induction is complete
17.03.2020 11:58
A nice generalisation for this one could be- For what initial positive integral values of $a_1$ does the sequence $a_n=a_{n-1}^2+6a_{n-1}, n>1$ have no perfect powers? Any ideas for this one? Here are few more possibilities of generalisations, but I have no clue if they are solvable. For what initial values does the sequence have atleast one perfect power? For what initial values does the sequence have infinitely many perfect powers?
18.09.2020 14:13
Assume that for some positive integer $n_0$ and some prime $p>3$ we have $v_p(a_{n_0})=1$ then we will prove that for all $n \ge n_0$ we have $v_p(a_n)=1$.The proof is of course inductive since $a_{n-1}|a_{n}$ for all $n$ all the terms after $a_{n_0}$ will be divisible by $p$ and: $v_p(a_{n+1})=v_p(a_n)+v_p(a_n+6)=v_p(a_n)=1$.The claim shows that if we find such $p,n_0$ we will be done and: $a_1=18,a_2=432,a_3=432*438$ so we choose $n_0=3,p=73$ the first terms can easily be checked by bare hands.
10.05.2021 19:20
It is easy to compute $a_2 = 432$ so $v_2(a_2) = 4$ and $v_3(a_2) = 3$. Since $a_n = a_{n-1}(a_{n-1} + 6)$, we have $v_2(a_n) = v_2(a_{n-1}) + v_2(a_{n-1} + 6) = 1 + v_2(a_{n-1})$ for all $n\geq 3$. And so we have $v_2(a_n) = n + 2$ for all $n\geq 3$. By a similar argument for $v_3$, we have $v_3(a_n) = v_3(a_{n-1}) + v_3(a_{n-1} + 6) = 1 + v_3(a_{n-1})$ for all $n\geq 3$. So we have $v_3(a_n) = n + 1$ for all $n\geq 3$. So for $n\geq 3$, since $v_2(a_n) = n + 2$ and $v_3(a_n) = n + 1$ and $\gcd{(n + 2 , n + 1)} = 1$, we cannot $a_n$ to be a perfect power and it is easy to see that $a_1$ and $a_2$ are both non-perfect powers. So we are done. $\square$
23.02.2022 12:50
bigant146 wrote: Let $a_n$ be a sequence given by $a_1 = 18$, and $a_n = a_{n-1}^2+6a_{n-1}$, for $n>1$. Prove that this sequence contains no perfect powers. $a_2 = a_1(a_1+6) = 18 \cdot 24 = 432,a_3 = a_2^2+6a_2 = 432 \cdot 438$ $$1 = v_{73}({a_3}) = v_{73}({a_4}) = ... = v_{73}({a_n}) = ...$$Remaining easy.$\blacksquare$
23.02.2022 13:58
Close it at consecutive square